History

Learn about the history of our church, from its humble beginnings to its growth as a vibrant community. Through faith, dedication, and service, we’ve faithfully served God and our community. Explore the key moments and milestones that continue to shape our mission today.
History

Both Presbyterians and American Baptists have a long history in the Canandaigua area. The Presbyterian Church was organized in 1870, and the present sanctuary building was dedicated in 1872. The American Baptist Church has an even longer history, with three different church buildings having been erected–the first in 1835.

On December 13, 1942, the First Baptist Church of Canandaigua was totally destroyed by fire. The Baptists held services in various buildings around town for five years. The Presbyterian Church offered to have them worship jointly. The offer was accepted May 11, 1947. In 1961, the name was formally changed to The United Church (Presbyterian-American Baptist) of Canandaigua, New York.

Since 1966, The United Church has only had three pastors. Rev. Fred Magley served from 1966-1989. Rev. Dr. Jim Kerr was called as Pastor in 1991, retiring in 2018. In 2021, Rev. Dr. Wade Allen began serving as Pastor.

First Baptist Church in Canandaigua was founded in 1835. The church was located on Main Street until it burned in 1942.

First Presbyterian Church in Canandaigua was organized in 1870 and has worshiped at 11 Gibson Street for its entire history.

Baptists and Presbyterians joined together in 1947 and officially became The United Church in 1961.

Additional Historical Information

The history of The United Church spans back to the 19th century. In 1870, Presbyterians bought the Barlow property and laid the cornerstone in 1871. The church has had 15 pastors, with Rev. Jim Kerr serving the longest tenure at 28 years. The church was renovated and renamed The United Church in 1961, reflecting the unity between the Presbyterian and American Baptist congregations. Significant events include:

  • 1942: The American Baptist Church was destroyed by fire.
  • 1947: Baptists began worshipping jointly with the Presbyterians.
  • 1973: The Christian Education Building was erected.
  • 1991: Rev. James Kerr began his pastorate.
  • 2015: A new pipe organ was completed.
  • 2018-2019: A Building Preservation Project restored windows, brickwork, and the front door.
  • 2021: Rev. Dr. Wade Allen began his pastorate.